Paradoks - Wykres - Krzysztof Polipowski

Paradoks - Wykres - Krzysztof Polipowski

/&
CA
D 5+ &
: ! "##
$%# &$ '(#) EF-.-<F=F=
G-HD<.D.<-I
! "# $
! % &' $ (
$ $ )
(
& '! (
&
*
+* ' ' )
&
'! *
&' & '! &
* ! & ( (
* ,
* -. $ $ "
#
+ $
$ -. /&
# (
*
0
&1 $ 2
$
$ 3
4 '! # #
$ 3(
#4
&
5
-. $ &$ 67 ! &
* 8$
( (
#
( 67 & !
#
!
0 &1 $
& $ 2 3 &
$'!4 9
#
!
$
&
$
(
#
(
2 3
#
#4 * # &
!
$
(
#
&
$
(
2 3
#4 * ' 9
&
!
$ (
2 3 &
4 &$ $
$ 0
-1
, -
, .
, . (
' &
$
&
* ' &
$ $ 0 &
$'!1 &
# ' &
0
# #1 &' #
&
' 0
#1 )
&
$ 0 &
1 , . (
&$ &
# #*(
*
: ; 0
-<1 '! ; 0
-<1 &
* & &
!
+
&
(
& $
= (
* $
> ( 8 ( & #
!
# ( 8 ( & !
( ? * ( )
* $ 5& 0,&
#*
1 * # ? 0@
=
,
&
A
1 * &$ (
)
(
B
#
! @
! &
#*!
8#$ J -KK-F.<-H @L& 9
B
- -I
/&
CA
D 5+ &
: ! "##
$%# &$ '(#) EF-.-<F=F=
G-HD<.D.<-I
& #& $ $ ! &
*' '
(
# #&
#
+ #& ( # $ )
& * ' # &
# = !
$ (
+
* #
)
& & +
*$ $
> 0 (1 $ * & 0
#
!
1 )
*
& ! * $ & )
(
& * $
& * !
&' & ! /&
* 2&
* !
& ! B'! 8$ & ! * & !
* $
&# 0 (1
B &
&
$ 8$* $ * ! ! M, (# 8$M "
#
&
$&# 3
'4 &'! &* ? ' KH KK.N 0
1 ?
> (0
1 0
1 &0
1 * 8#$ J -KK-F.<-H @L& 9
B
. -I
/&
CA
D 5+ &
: ! "##
$%# &$ '(#) EF-.-<F=F=
G-HD<.D.<-I
,T982T
B@UP)@V8@
-<
,7"75?)@T
<
<
<
<
?,XYD,TZ9T5B72)XY -<
<
-<
<
-<
TP"T5??)@T
<
<
<
B=/B5)9T)@T
-<
<
-<
<
-<
/T87"72)XY
<
<
<
<
/79=82
-<
<
-<
<
-<
7=@"=
<
<
<
<
=8DA8"7))XY
-<
/>6@?$"
$#
?
8#$ J -KK-F.<-H @L& 9
<
T9B78")XY
8@T]DT=@
-<
5)BA9?)@T
-<
*12 :0/+*
-<
,P)@"?)@T
*34,+/
-<
BT,7?)XY
*..+90,+-
T5BT,7=T)?)@T
-<
.-8-4*,+-
-<
?7,?]XY
+,,*/
-<
B"8"T,XY
6*7,+6/
","U/")@TB,TBT=
)9@"?)@T"P,[T\
6+-3*,+-
-<
B==7?82
*20/
-<
<
,T9@"?)@T
@)A@872)XY
B=58T82
=7??)@T
*123-4,+- 1+-5+-
A,"7=7?)@T
1232-4+
-<
)9@78")XY
*.-*,+- .-/0+
-<
T?)XY
@)@82?)@T
*+,+-
,"7?W/"?
-<
<
)9@"?)@T"P,[T\
-<
/> A$"
$#
?
B
; -I
/&
CA
D 5+ &
: ! "##
$%# &$ '(#) EF-.-<F=F=
G-HD<.D.<-I
*+,+-
T?)XY
-<
!" # ! ! ! " . ;<=> > (
? @ A
-,*BC
(' (
$ *232*BC3-D8-610,*BC
<
<?,XYD,TZ9T5B72)XY
-<
& $ /$ @% (
?
*5+-620+ F $ +(
& * $ $ 0 $: '! $: '!D,+&'!1
,+-.-/0.*,+- F * &
(
&' $
0 $: '! $: '!D,+&'!1
.*420 F ' (
$ ' ( 0 $: '! $: '!D,+&'!1
,-7238,*BC F ' ' (
$ #
$
( 0 $: '! $: '!D,+&'!1
*(#
#?
?
' $ B
8 '! $ ( #& '! (
#
"& '! ' (
$ (
' = ( ' '
(
$ # ? &
# !
$
& '&
8$
'! ' (
$ #& * & ( '& & = $ 8* '! ( $ & * ! $ # $ & ( +
$
0 1 * *' !
* ' $ '
8#$ J -KK-F.<-H @L& 9
B
O -I
/&
CA
D 5+ &
: ! "##
$%# &$ '(#) EF-.-<F=F=
G-HD<.D.<-I
*.-*,+- .-/0+
-<
$ !
!
!
" !
%!
)9@78")XY
. ;<=> > (
? @ A
,8+20/,*BC
&## +
0 &' &1
+,27+/0,*BC
! 0 &' 1
<
<
@)A@872)XY
-<
/$ @% (
?
8*4+/, +,27+/ F & & ( 0
$: &'! $: @'!1
+33/*,8,*BC F &#
# &
&
& & 0
$: &'! $: @'!1
,+68+*BC F &' * 0 $:
&'! $: @'!1
,+-+,2-3-1*,+- .-/0+ F &
+
(
0 $: &'! $: @'!1
*(#
#?
=
* &
& 8 '!
P
& * & ! * = ('! &' #& * ' ? &
* 8 & + #
& (& &
8 ! ' #! &# 8 #& & +
$
* *' !
&# &
8#$ J -KK-F.<-H @L& 9
B
I -I
/&
CA
D 5+ &
: ! "##
$%# &$ '(#) EF-.-<F=F=
G-HD<.D.<-I
1232-4+
-<
&
'"# ! !
'
!
,7"75?)@T
. ;<=> > (
? @ A
3006*,+
+ **
'!
,8+*,+- 43*:-E
(
# &$ ' &
& #
<
<
)9@"?)@T"P,[T\ -<
/$ @% (
?
3*:,*BC F &
&$ #>
$ &
& # 0 $: ,
$: &
"
#>1
*123*:,*BC F * &$ #
$ $ &
& # ' ' 0 $: ,
$: &
"
#>1
+7810,*BC F # &
&$ '
0 $: ,
$: &
"
#>1
1-673,/2* F ' ' * # & #
&
& # 0 $: ,
$:
&
"
#>1
*(#
#?
$*! #
+ &
! &$ ' &
# ! & # # 2
* # &
&$ (
'! (
$ # & 2'& +
* #
**
# ! ! 2
&
* ! * ' ' 2'&
& ! '! & $
0 1 * !
&' 8 ( &
# '! & $
' ! ' & $ 8 ' +
!Q
8#$ J -KK-F.<-H @L& 9
B
H -I
/&
CA
D 5+ &
: ! "##
$%# &$ '(#) EF-.-<F=F=
G-HD<.D.<-I
*123-4,+- 1+-5+-
&
! " !! ! "
!' ' (
! % ) ' '
# "
% ' B=58T82
-<
. ;<=> > (
? @ A
1*6/-2/
& 032 41
<
<
B=/B5)9T)@T
-<
1*.*16*,8-,+
& &
/$ @% (
?
.3* 1**/-, F $ $ &
0 $: B
$: B
&1
1*63020/0 F &
* 0 $:
B
$: B
&1
.-D-,10,*BC F $* &
* 0 $: B
$: B
&1
,+:*, 1**/-, F #
&
* 0 $: B
$: B
&1
*(#
#?
('! &
*
& * ( '! &
(
' ?
& '! # +
* $*! 8 * (
* ('! (
#
(
8 *'! # $
0 1 * # !
"
$
& *' #
* !
+' $
8#$ J -KK-F.<-H @L& 9
B
R -I
/&
CA
D 5+ &
: ! "##
$%# &$ '(#) EF-.-<F=F=
G-HD<.D.<-I
*20/
*' "
'
! ! ! '
! + "
B==7?82
-<
. ;<=> > (
? @ A
1**20/
#
> ' &
3F.,+- 123-1-
<
<
","U/")@TB,TBT=
-<
&
* /$ @% (
?
620,*BC F 0
$: B
$: "
B1
5-23*16 F &
+& 0
$: B
$: "
B1
,+G/+- F #*
0 $: B
$: "
B1
10,*BC F #*
* D& & 0 $: B
$: "
B1
*(#
#?
& * *
= &#
! & & &
* ( & $! # &' '
! &
+
$
0
1
* ( !
' ( !
*
8 ( &
# # #*! & &'! ! # $
* 8#$ J -KK-F.<-H @L& 9
B
S -I
/&
CA
D 5+ &
: ! "##
$%# &$ '(#) EF-.-<F=F=
G-HD<.D.<-I
6+-3*,+-
-<
, ! !# % %
" !
TP"T5??)@T
. ;<=> > (
? @ A
-4-6*,+
&#
#
! $ #(
/+-9*-2+
$ ! $
<
<
8@T]DT=@
-<
/$ @% (
?
1+-3F/- -4-6*,+- F #
*$ #( (
0 $: T#
$: 8(DT
1
*59:8+*BC F (
#
$ 0
$: T#
$: 8(DT
1
173**BC F #
# &
0 $: T#
$: 8(DT
1
,+-,4:*,+- F (
#
$ 0 $: T#
$: 8(DT
1
*(#
#?
C! & #
! #( ! $ #
'& =
('! & *# (
( (# (
& + ' #
('! (
#' & (
&' $ #
& & &
+
$
0
1 * (' !
(
&' & !
# #
8 ( & # # ( $
! * #
! '& ' * ! (
&'!
8#$ J -KK-F.<-H @L& 9
B
K -I
/&
CA
D 5+ &
: ! "##
$%# &$ '(#) EF-.-<F=F=
G-HD<.D.<-I
6*7,+6/
-<
- # % !
"
# ! % !
!
B"8"T,XY
. ;<=> > (
? @ A
1/-3*BC
& ' .08*/
'&
<
<
/79=82
-<
/$ @% (
?
*232 .08*/ F ' ( 0 $:
B'! $: /&
1
0+,+- F ' '' 0 $: B'! $: /&
1
5-/-3-*,+8,*BC F & ' &
&
0 $: B'! $: /&
1
7,+6,+- 6*7,+6/+ F ' &
0 $: B'! $: /&
1
*(#
#?
"
('! &' '& '! ' =
('! ' ! * * (
&
$ *
' ( &
' &
8 !
* (
*'! * &
8 ! * &
' /
(
! &
& &' # ?*'! '! +
$
0 1 * *' !
&
*'! ('! 8#$ J -KK-F.<-H @L& 9
B
-< -I
/&
CA
D 5+ &
: ! "##
$%# &$ '(#) EF-.-<F=F=
G-HD<.D.<-I
+,,*/
-<
! !
! !
.
?7,?]XY
. ;<=> > (
? @ A
0239*BC
( $
-61-30-,2*,+
$ $
$ <
<
T5BT,7=T)?)@T
-<
/$ @% (
?
63-20,*BC F (
& & &
0 $: ?
('! $: T
1
536 0239*B/+ F * & (
> $ >
0 $: ?
('! $: T
1
6*,1-320 F '
0 $: ?
('! $: T
1
124,/ F (' $ 0 $: ?
('! $: T
1
*(#
#?
=
('! (' > & $ 8 '! ! $ (' &
8 ( &
('! *
' ( 2
! '
* ( ? + $
! ('! * '&#
(# &
+
$
0 1 *' !
' *' !
=
( ( &
# ('! $
! *
8#$ J -KK-F.<-H @L& 9
B
-- -I
/&
CA
D 5+ &
: ! "##
$%# &$ '(#) EF-.-<F=F=
G-HD<.D.<-I
.-8-4*,+-
-<
/
'# % ' # /T87"72)XY
. ;<=> > (
? @ A
.-/00,*BC
# (
$*! *
&' 6*,1782*,+
(
<
<
5)BA9?)@T
-<
/$ @% (
?
*.*+-.+8, 1H93/ F &' &
( $ 0 $: /'! $:
5&
1
**12+,+- .-/0+ F $ 0
$: /'! $: 5&
1
.-/0- 5- 1H93/0 F &# (
0 $: /'! $: 5&
1
7,+6,+- .-/0+ F &' & 0 $: /'! $: 5&
1
*(#
#?
& # (
$*! &' C! 8* (
! & #*
(
$ &
#'! *
(
&
8 & * (
&' & ! = ! ('! (
# (
* $*! (
? + ! ('! & ' &
! 8 '# (
#( &! '! $ = $
! * $ #
$
+
$
0 1 * ( !
& (
* (
' &'!
"
* ( !
(
&
! =
( ( & # %& * $
! * ( &' &
8#$ J -KK-F.<-H @L& 9
B
-. -I
/&
CA
D 5+ &
: ! "##
$%# &$ '(#) EF-.-<F=F=
G-HD<.D.<-I
*..+90,+-
-<
, ' ! !
BT,7?)XY
. ;<=> > (
? @ A
1-320,*BC
$ #> **/7/0,,*BC
#
$ #
&
$ #
$ &
<
<
=8DA8"7))XY
-<
/$ @% (
?
1H93/ F > &
$ $ 0 $: '! $: DA'!1
*B+G/,+- 1+G F #
$ # (
$ 0 $: '! $: DA'!1
.*+,/ F ' ' (
$ $ 0 $: '! $: DA'!1
0/*D,+- F ' ' 0 $: '! $:
DA'!1
*(#
#?
= & ! &
(
=
('! & '
$
/* $* ('! $ &
$ (
?
(
' #'! * $ &
$ (
>
2
#'! *
'&
(
$ ! '*
+
$
0
&1 * *' !
(
*' !
'*
* 8 ( & # # ( $
! * ! * '& & $*! #
8#$ J -KK-F.<-H @L& 9
B
-; -I
/&
CA
D 5+ &
: ! "##
$%# &$ '(#) EF-.-<F=F=
G-HD<.D.<-I
*34,+/
-<
(' # # # / ! ! ' !
,P)@"?)@T
. ;<=> > (
? @ A
*34,+*,+
-8120/,*BC
(
# * <
<
T9B78")XY
-<
/$ @% (
?
-8120/, *34,+/ F #
$
&
'
0 $: #
$: T&
'!1
/I*1 F * ' #
0 $:
#
$: T&
'!1
,+--8120/,- *34,+*,+- F # *
0 $: #
$: T&
'!1
.-*34,+/ F #
&' $ 0 $:
#
$: T&
'!1
*(#
#?
C! & & #
! =
('! * 8* '!
('! &
' &
8 * 5 &' *
* (! # 2
&
'! ! *
$ $ ! ! & +
$
0 1 * *' !
&
# #
& *' !
$
*'! $
! '! #
& * *'! ! 8 ( & # # ( $
! * !
* 8#$ J -KK-F.<-H @L& 9
B
-O -I
/&
CA
D 5+ &
: ! "##
$%# &$ '(#) EF-.-<F=F=
G-HD<.D.<-I
*12 :0/+*
-<
* ' !
"
' . ;<=> > (
? @ A
7=@"=
*20+
('!
,8+*,+- 43*:-E
(
# &$ ' &
& #
<
<
)9@"?)@T"P,[T\ -<
/$ @% (
?
3-8+120/,0 *20+ F &
&$ #> &
& # $
# ' &$ ' 0 $: $: &
"
#>1
1/-20/0 F # '&
&$ ' $ &
& #
# '&
&$ ' 0 $: $:
&
"
#>1
,+-*3,0 *20+ F * &$ '
$ $ &
&
# #
&$ ' 0 $: $: &
"
#>1
-10+ F ('! 0 $:
$: &
"
#>1
*(#
#?
=
('! (# # $
' '
$
* (
& &
= &! ! ' &
&$ ' &
# ! #
& ' #
8 ! ( # 2
& &
! &$ & ! * (
! * # &$ & +
$
0 1 * *' !
&# *'! * &# 2
*
*' !
# *'! !
! +
* $ &
#
8 ( & # (
* '& ! * # &* * %&
8#$ J -KK-F.<-H @L& 9
B
-I -I